|
Manipulation under anesthesia for pain
This procedure, manipulation under anesthesia (MUA), is a non-invasive
procedure increasingly offered for acute and chronic conditions, including:
neck pain, back pain, joint pain, muscle spasm, shortened muscles, fibrous
adhesions and long term pain syndromes. It is generally considered safe and is
utilized to treat pain arising from the cervical, thoracic and lumbar spine as
well as the sacroiliac and pelvic regions.
Manipulation under anesthesia uses a combination of specific short lever
manipulations, passive stretches and specific articular and postural
kinesthetic maneuvers in order to break up
fibrous adhesions and scar tissue
around the spine and surrounding tissue.
The manipulation procedures can be offered in any of the following ways:
-
Under general anesthesia
-
During mild sedation
-
Following the injection of anesthetic solutions into specific tissues of the
spine.
The treatment is performed in a hospital or surgery center by licensed
physicians with specialized training and certification specifically for the
procedure. A team approach is required to have a safe and successful outcome.
The team includes the anesthesiologist, the prime
physician/surgeon/chiropractor who performs the manipulation, and the first
assistant, also a physician/chiropractor certified in manipulation under
anesthesia. The procedure is commonly performed in a hospital or surgical
center.
The combination of manipulation and anesthesia is not new, as this treatment
has been part of the manual medical arena for more than 60 years.Manipulation
Under Anesthesia is an established medical procedure with a CPT Code designate
of 22505. This is noted in the American Medical Association’s Current
Procedural Terminology Publication.
Which patients should be considered for manipulation under anesthesia?
Certain neck, mid back, low back or other spinal conditions respond poorly to
conventional care. One proposed theory for this is that, as a result of past or
present injury,
adhesions and scar tissue
have built up around spinal joints and within the surrounding muscles and
causes chronic pain.
Patients often undergo various treatments, such as physical therapy,
chiropractic care, epidural injections, back surgery, or other treatments that
do not address fibrous adhesions. Some patients feel temporarily better with
these treatments, but their pain often returns.
In general, patients selected for manipulation under anesthesia are those who
have received conservative care for six to eight weeks. If limited or no
improvements in symptoms or objective findings have occurred, then manipulation
under anesthesia may be an appropriate alternative.
Prior to treatment, protocols of diagnostic testing should document the nature
of the diagnosis, support the need for treatment and eliminate questions of
psychosocial factors that can influence pain responses. In addition to X-ray,
MRI scan or CT scan, a musculoskeletal sonogram or nerve conduction velocity
test may be ordered.
Proposed effects
The proposed effects of manipulation under anesthesia therapy include the
following:
-
Breaking up scar tissue (adhesions) both in and around the spinal joints,
commonly caused by multiple injuries or failed back surgery
-
Decreasing chronic muscle spasm
-
Overcoming super sensitivity of injured areas, making the patient unable to
cooperate for effective treatment
-
Stretching persistent shortened muscles, ligaments and tendons
-
Relieving pain and radiating symptoms from damaged intervertebral discs. Some
disc injuries are serious enough to require surgery, but these types of
injuries are relatively infrequent.
-
Chrisman et al: “A study of the results following manipulation in lumbar disc
syndrome.” Journal of bone and Joint Surgery 46A, 1964.
-
Saal et al: “The natural history of lumbar disc extrusions treated
non-operatively.: Spine, Vol 15, 1990.
-
Kohlbeck FJ, Haldeman S, “Medication-assisted spinal manipulation.” The Spine
Journal, Volume 2 (4), 2002.
Anesthesia and Manipulation
Of course, when movement of the spine is extremely and intolerably painful to
the patient, the benefit of being under anesthesia and unconscious is obvious.
In addition, the anesthesia performs other equally important functions, such as:
-
Shutting off the muscle spasm cycle to allow spinal movement
-
Sedating the pain-perceiving nerves that have been irritated due to the
dysfunctional spine
-
Allowing complete muscle relaxation to allow the doctor to stretch shortened
muscle groups and to break up adhesions caused by scar tissue.
Indications and contraindications
In general, patients selected for manipulation under anesthesia have received a
minimum of six to eight weeks of conservative care. Additionally, there are a
number of specific indications and contraindications that need to considered
prior to undertaking manipulation under anesthesia, including:
Indications
-
Neck, mid back and low back pain
-
Chronic muscle pain and inflammation
-
Acute and chronic muscle spasm
-
Decreased spinal range of motion
-
Chronic fibrositis
-
Nerve entrapment
-
Pseudo-sciatica
-
Sciatica where disc bulges are contained less than 5 mm
-
Failed back surgery
-
Chronic occipital or tension headaches
-
Conditions where narcotic pain relievers are of little benefit
-
Traumatic torticollis
-
RSD
Contraindications
Contraindication to anesthesia as determined by current medical literature and
is the responsibility of the licensed medical co-manager (anesthesiologist).
Contraindications to manual manipulation of high velocity, low velocity or soft
tissue techniques as established by current literature relative to technique
specific for articular derangements, bone weakening and destruction disorders,
circulatory and cardiovascular disorders, or neurological disorders.
Specific contraindications to manipulation of the spine under anesthesia
include:
-
Malignancy with metastasis to bone
-
Tuberculosis of the bone
-
Fractures
-
Acute arthritis
-
Acute gout
-
Uncontrolled diabetic neuropathy
-
Syphilitic articular or periarticular lesions
-
Gonorrheal spinal arthritis
-
Excessive spinal osteoporosis
-
Evidence of cord or caudal compression by tumor, ankylosis and malacia bone
disease.
Evaluation of the Patient
Candidates are selected for manipulation under anesthesia after obtaining an
adequate history, thorough physical examination, and the appropriate diagnostic
imaging and laboratory procedures necessary for an accurate diagnosis of the
underlying condition.
History and physical
The burden of proof for medical necessity rests with the treating doctor. It
should be substantially documented in the patient’s history and physical, with
specific emphasis on: the failure to respond to conservative means in the
history; indication of fibrosis and/or myofibrosis in the physical examination;
and any supportive diagnostic testing as indicated and warranted by medical
necessity of the patient’s condition.
A complete physical examination is performed paying special attention to motion
palpation of the spine and a visual inspection and palpation of the skin
(manifestation of sympathetic nervous system changes including edema, tissue
texture, increase or decrease of moisture, temperature changes, etc).
Additionally, digital palpation identifies increased or decreased changes in
muscle and fascia tone which lead to altered biomechanics.
Laboratory exam
Laboratory examinations should be performed to further evaluate patient health.
They not only contribute to differential diagnosis, but they also help the
medical saff assess patient health prior to going under anesthesia. Females of
child bearing years should be evaluated for pregnancy.
Females of child bearing years should be evaluated for pregnancy. A male past
40 years of age should also have the following test done: serum alkaline and
acid phosphatase. After completion of the preliminary work, other laboratory
procedures may be indicated.
Radiographic examination
Anterior-posterior (front/back) and lateral (side) radiographs of the joints
involved should be taken. Additionally, extension and lateral bending views may
be of benefit in visualizing loss of function. Many times one may want a
detailed view of the joints which are to be manipulated under anesthesia.
Motion studies on fluoroscopy may be helpful.
Studies should be repeated after serial manipulation under anesthesia to see
what changes have been affected by the procedure. When warranted, CT Scan
and/or MRI scan of the spine should be employed to rule out or confirm
suspected pathology.
Electrodiagnostic tests
Electrodiagnostic studies of the appropriate spinal outflows should be
performed to rule out specific neurological dysfunction. These tests confirm or
differentiate diagnosis of neuropathy, radiculopathy or plexopathy. They show
the presence or lack of nerve compression and localize and assess the degree of
injury along the course of a nerve.
Ultrasound studies
Musculoskeletal diagnostic ultrasound is a test used to visualize soft tissue
structures and identify signs of inflammation and scar tissue (adhesions)
around joints, nerve roots, tendons, ligaments and muscle. This test is
important because it confirms the presence of adhesions and medical need for
maniuplation under anesthesia.
Manipulative Techniques
Techniques under anesthesia may vary from patient to patient as medical
necessity indicates by the involved tissues and existing relative
contraindications and/or possible complications that may exist. Some of the
techniques include:
Soft tissue procedures
- lateral stretching, linear stretching, deep pressure, traction and/or
separation of muscle origin and insertion.
|
Tissue:
|
periarticular
|
|
Goals:
|
decrease muscle spasm and increase tissue mobility
|
Articulatory procedures (mobilization without impulse, low velocity techniques)
- placing articulation through full anatomic range of motion. A passive
serial
repetitive oscillatory rhythmic springing force in the direction of
restriction.
|
Tissue:
|
periarticular and articular
|
|
Goals:
|
increase quantity of motion - gradual movement
of restrictive barrier to restore range of motion increase quality of
motion - smooth range of movement with normal elastic and feel
|
Specific joint mobilization procedure
- mobilization with impulse, high
velocity technique. Extrinsic operator applied thrust overcoming restrictive
articular movement. Engagement of the restrictive barrier and thrust through
the barrier to achieve normal joint movement.
|
Tissue:
|
articular and intra articular
|
|
Goals:
|
increase joint range of motion reduce joint
restrictions reduction of hyper tonicity stretch shortened fibrosed
connective
tissues of the articulation
|
Post Operative Care
The patient should experience an immediate increase in range of motion, even
though there is usually some temporarily added muscle soreness similar to
feeling of having completed an aggressive exercise session. In cases involving
symptoms caused by disturbance from adhesions and shortened tissues, there
should be a significant change, either immediately or within a short period
following the procedures.
In effort to minimize the re-formation of adhesions, passive manipulation and
active exercises are prescribed. Some use of additional therapies may also be
prescribed, such as:
-
Electrical muscle stimulation
-
Ultrasound
-
Hot moist packs
-
Massage
The most important post operative care is an active rehabilitation program,
starting within one to two weeks after the manipulation under anesthesia
procedure and lasting for a minimum of four to six weeks.
|